logo

30 pages 1 hour read

Breaking Night: A Memoir of Forgiveness, Survival, and My Journey from Homeless to Harvard

Nonfiction | Autobiography / Memoir | Adult | Published in 2010

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 10-12 & EpilogueChapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 10 Summary

Liz starts having recurring nightmares in which she turns her back on her mother and abandons her in her hour of need. In the daytime, she understands that this is her guilt manifesting—guilt that she didn’t go back and see her mother again after she visited with Lisa at the hospital. She and Sam stay with Carlos and celebrate the New Year, but the next day, Carlos vanishes again. The motel manager tells Liz and Sam that they’ll have to leave unless they can pay for another night by checkout time.

Out of money, they leave the motel. Liz and Sam end up parting ways when Sam goes to stay with Oscar. Carlos finds Liz at her friend Jamie’s house, and she accompanies him to another motel. This particular motel is nothing like the others they have stayed in—it’s more run down and is often used by prostitutes and their clientele. Carlos continues to vanish for days at a time, leaving Liz alone. She’s afraid to leave though, because she doesn’t know how she’d survive on the street by herself. She doesn’t even know where she is.

When a woman is stabbed and killed by her boyfriend in the motel, Liz decides that she’s had enough. Carlos is acting more violent toward her and she fears for her safety. Liz leaves and goes to stay with friends. During this time, she learns that Sam has found her way to a group home, and while hurt that Sam didn’t contact her, Liz is relieved that her friend is safe. When Liz feels like she has outstayed her welcome at her friends’ parents’ apartments, she starts sleeping in hallways and on the subway.

Liz decides she wants to graduate from high school. Approaching her seventeenth birthday, she researches and applies to alternative high schools all over Manhattan. She interviews and receives rejection after rejection. During her last interview, she confides in one of the teachers, Perry, about her story. She’s accepted but the school requires an adult to register her, since she’s not yet eighteen. She manages to find her dad, and he registers her for school.

Chapter 11 Summary

School won’t start for a few months, so Liz searches the classifieds for a job. She manages to find work with the New York Public Institute of Research, a non-profit organization that is collecting funds to help the environment. Liz gets a job canvassing neighborhoods and collecting donations. Because she works on commission, the more she collects, the more she earns. At first, her supervisors don’t think she can perform, but she doubles her quota, so they start sending her to more upscale, suburban areas. One of her coworkers, Ken, often canvasses with her, and Liz starts to develop a crush on him.

While riding the subway, Liz sees Sam in a train opposite the platform. Their gazes meet and they eventually get off at the same stop so that they can give one another a hug and catch up. Liz feels left out when Sam talks about her friends at the group home, but then she suggests that Sam apply for the same alternative high school she’ll be attending (Liz calls it Prep) and Sam does.

Later, Liz goes to a sleepover at Ken’s family’s home. She has a plan to earn Ken’s affections that begins with snagging a sleeping bag right next to him. As the party of NYPIRG workers talks about college, Liz starts to wonder if college might be something she could do. When it comes time to sleep, she’s delighted to find that Ken is next to her, but when she hears him snoring she knows that no romantic advances will occur that night.

The next morning, after seeing Ken interact with another girl named Anna, Liz realizes Ken doesn’t have feelings for her—he was just being nice. Overwhelmed by all that Ken and his family represent—wealth and family solidarity—Liz bursts out into laughter and feels embarrassed.

Chapter 12 Summary

Liz hopes to complete four years of high school in only two years, so she fills up her schedule with classes at Prep and other schools. Not only does she want to finish quickly, she wants top marks. However, Liz soon discovers that this is easier said than done, and often faces the battle of trying to make herself wake up and go to class instead of sleeping in. She manages to get to school, though, and soon finds that she would not want to disappoint her teachers.

Time passes and Liz starts to not only tolerate school, but to love it—she loves her teachers and she loves learning. For the first time in a long time, she feels hopeful about her future. She makes a new friend named Eva who often takes her in, offers her food, and gives her clothing. Shortly after, she befriends another student named James, and their friendship morphs into a romantic relationship. Unlike with Carlos, Liz finds their sexual encounters rewarding. When she doesn’t stay at Eva’s apartment, she stays at James’s.

Later, she meets up with her father, who confides in her that he’s been diagnosed as HIV positive. He asks her not to tell Lisa. At first, this angers and frustrates Liz, but then she realizes that her father loves her, and she ultimately forgives him.

Sam attends Prep, too; she works with Liz and Eva on a project about HIV/AIDS, and they earn top grades. Liz and Sam get an apartment with Lisa, but right after they all move in together, Lisa loses her job. Liz is instantly thrust back into fearing for immediate needs such as food and rent. They’re denied welfare, and Liz knows that if she’s going to graduate as fast as she’d like, she can’t stop going to school in order to work. She starts to feel stuck.

She applies for, and wins, a scholarship through the New York Times. Her story is published and she receives national support. People pay her back rent and ask if they can save her time by doing her laundry, and other favors. Liz starts to hope again, and applies to Harvard. She is waitlisted. When she finds out that the university has sent its admission decision, she waits for the mailman to deliver the letter.

Epilogue Summary

The epilogue finds Liz in Buenos Aires, Argentina, where she’s waiting for the Dalai Lama to give a presentation. She’s the speaker after him. Liz is invited to ask the final question during the Dalai Lama’s presentation, but before she shares with the reader what her question was—or what the Dalai Lama’s answer was—she takes a couple of pages to explain how she has come to this point, about to follow the Dalai Lama and to speak to seven hundred CEOs from all over the world. Her experiences leading up to and while studying at Harvard inspired Liz to create a series of workshops meant to empower others.

Peter quit using drugs after receiving his HIV diagnosis. His other medical concerns included a damaged heart that required open-heart surgery, hepatitis C, and cirrhosis of the liver. Lisa and Sam managed to reach their goals in school. Sam got married and moved to Wisconsin with her husband and Lisa became a school teacher. Prior to Peter’s death, Liz and her friend Ed were able to take him on one last trip to San Francisco to see the favorite places of his youth. Peter died three weeks after that trip, at the age of sixty-four, after spending the last eight of those years sober.

Returning to the Dalai Lama, Liz reveals her question, which was, “Your Holiness, you inspire so many people, but what inspires you?” (326). His answer was that he didn’t know—he was “just a simple monk.” Afterward, CEOs approach Liz to tell her their interpretations of his answer. Some say it’s simplicity. Others say it’s not knowing things. One CEO claimed the Dalai Lama was arrogant. She finds out backstage that in fact the Dalai Lama never knew her question because the interpreter didn’t translate it properly. Liz decides that“life takes on the meaning that you give it” (328).

Chapters 10-12 & Epilogue Analysis

This last quarter of Liz Murray’s memoir is all about acceptance, forgiveness, and taking her life into her own hands. She accepts and forgives her father because she knows he loves her and that he would never intend to do her harm. She even accepts and forgives Carlos’s actions, knowing that when he scared her, it was because he was high. Once she does this, Liz is truly able to take control in her life of the things she can change, the things she can impact.

This empowers her. She has the ability to work hard to try to finish school quickly and with good grades. She has the ability to apply for scholarships and interview for them. She has the ability to apply for Harvard. She doesn’t have control over the outcomes, and she comes to terms with that. While much of Breaking Night is about Liz forgiving her parents, it’s also about forgiving herself. At the end of the book, she must learn to let go of the past hurdles that kept her from the success she seeks in order to come to terms with whatever the outcome is.

By working hard, she not only meets her goals but exceeds them in unexpected ways. One example of this is that after she wins the scholarship from the New York Times. Liz is certain that when her story goes out into the world, she will face negative results. She’s pleasantly surprised by the outpouring of public support across the nation from people who feel inspired by her unwillingness to give up.

In the epilogue, her exchange with the Dalai Lama teaches her that one can feel certain of something yet still be wrong. She writes that she had been certain there were walls between her and what she wanted, but that those walls didn’t actually exist once she took responsibility for her own life, a process which could only come after forgiveness.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 30 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools